Key West Key Lime Pie Co.
Bakeries · Key West, FL
About
RealReviews profileKey West Key Lime Pie Co. is a dedicated key-lime dessert and retail shop at 1108 Duval Street. The company sells slices, whole pies, frozen chocolate-dipped pie bars, and key-lime products, making it a practical southern-Duval comparison stop. RealReviews has verified the record against the official domain and address but does not yet display a source-attributed rating aggregate.
Key West Key Lime Pie Co.: what to know
RealReviews editorial research · checked 2026-07-24Key West Key Lime Pie Co. fits travelers near the southern half of Duval Street who want a dedicated dessert counter, a slice-to-go, frozen chocolate-dipped format, or retail products. It should be compared as a shop, not as a restaurant experience, and current inventory should be confirmed before a special trip.
Strongest fit
- A Duval Street dessert stop
- Slices and frozen pie bars
- Whole-pie or packaged-product questions
- Comparing specialist-shop styles
Check before choosing
- The profile currently lacks an outside rating aggregate
- Retail and recipe offerings can change
- Cold products need a storage plan
- Brand history does not replace product-specific review evidence
Why the exact shop identity matters
The verified record points to 1108 Duval Street and the company’s official domain. Key West contains several similarly named pie shops and many directory duplicates, so address and domain matching are essential before merging reviews or making a recommendation. This page concerns this business, not every shop with “Key Lime Pie” in its name.
The official store sells pie and a wider line of key-lime products. A rating or review about shipping, candy, or service should not automatically become a claim about a fresh slice. Product-level reading keeps the profile useful.
How to use it in a pie crawl
The southern Duval address pairs naturally with the Southernmost Point area and the lower end of Old Town. It can contrast with Blue Heaven’s seated meringue-topped restaurant dessert or with Kermit’s Elizabeth Street flagship near the Historic Seaport. Two distinct formats are more informative than several rushed specialist counters.
Ask what topping and serving temperature apply to the available slice. Note crust, filling, lime intensity, sweetness, and topping ratio. A frozen chocolate-coated bar should be judged as its own dessert rather than as a substitute for a plated slice.
Buying a whole pie or taking products home
Confirm whole-pie availability, serving estimate, topping, packaging, refrigeration, pickup cutoff, and cancellation before planning an event. A hot car or long outdoor walk can damage a chilled custard dessert. Ask the staff how long the purchased format can travel.
For shipping or packaged goods, read current fulfillment terms and delivery timing on the official site. Frozen, refrigerated, and shelf-stable products may have different methods. Do not promise an arrival for an occasion until the order confirmation supports it.
Transparent treatment of an empty review state
This profile does not currently show an external rating aggregate and has not accumulated a meaningful first-party RealReviews review set. That is an evidence limitation, not a hidden zero. RealReviews fills the page with verified identity, source links, decision guidance, review submission, and correction tools rather than fake testimonials.
A visitor can still evaluate fit through the official product offering, direct answers, the condition of the actual purchase, and recent independent feedback found under the exact address. Owners can claim the page and add accurate operational information without buying favorable treatment.
Before you book or visit
- Match the 1108 Duval address.
- Confirm current slice style and inventory.
- Keep frozen products cold.
- Ask about whole-pie timing.
- Check allergy and cross-contact details.
- Add a first-party review only after a real visit.
Common needs in this category
Category guidance · confirm directlyProfile evidence
What supports this pageThis is a research and comparison profile—not a claim that RealReviews has personally used the business. External ratings stay attributed, firsthand submissions stay separate, and corrections remain visible through the profile workflow.
Ask about an order with Key West Key Lime Pie Co.
Check bakery order availabilityCompare ratings, review themes, profile details, and corrections before sending a structured ask about an order inquiry.
Firsthand customer feedback
Open for genuine experiencesTell future customers what you hired Key West Key Lime Pie Co. for, how communication and pricing worked, and what you would want someone else to know. Every submission is checked before publication.
- Describe a genuine firsthand experience
- Add useful context such as timing, scope, or cost
- Positive, mixed, and negative experiences are welcome
Review and reputation themes
6 attributed or submitted themesQuestions to ask before hiring
Ask a questionPeople also compare
Nearby profilesHow RealReviews handles this profile
Profile trust and correctionsBefore you hire
- Ask for written scope, warranty, and insurance details.
- Use RealReviews to keep selected quote details trackable.
- Suggest a correction if any profile detail looks inaccurate.
Contact and quote requests use RealReviews so users can compare options without chasing separate forms.