Highest rated listings

Highest rated Italian Restaurants in Key West, FL

Compare Italian Restaurants in Key West, FL. Use the sort controls to compare ratings, review counts, activity, and profile details.

Plan a meal

Request a table in Key West, FL

Share the date, preferred time, party size, and occasion with selected restaurants.

✓ Choose the restaurants✓ Add seating needs✓ Reservation requires confirmation

The restaurant must confirm the reservation.

Abbondanza Italian Restaurant

Italian Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Bel Mare

Italian Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Big John's Pizzeria

Italian Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.0 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Bruschetta Francesca

Italian Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.7 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Clemente's Wood-Fired Trolley Pizzeria

Italian Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

La Trattoria Restaurant

Italian Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

New York Pasta Garden

Italian Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Onlywood Grill

Italian Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

The Luihn Four

Italian Restaurants · Key West, FL

0.5 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction