Highest rated listings

Highest rated Jewelry Stores in Key West, FL

A ranked listings view for Jewelry Stores in Key West, FL. Use the sort controls to compare public ratings, review counts, and profile details.

Need jewelry stores in Key West, FL?

Tell us what you need and get matched with top local options.

Ballerina Jewelers

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

5.0 · 396 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 8 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Shipwreck Treasures of the Keys

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

5.0 · 358 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 8 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Emeralds International, LLC

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.7 mi

5.0 · 350 Reviews

Web DesignReligious OrganizationsAssociation Or Organization+3

Bliss Jewelers

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.8 mi

5.0 · 333 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 9 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Flores Gold & Diamonds (Appointment Only)

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

5.0 · 53 Reviews

Jewelry StoreStore

Keys Gear & Jewelry Design

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

5.0 · 41 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 7 PM

Gift ShopJewelry StoreWholesaler+2

Online Now

GreyeWolfe

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.7 mi

5.0 · 38 Reviews

Jewelry StoreStore

Permanent Jewelry Key West MAVKA

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.7 mi

5.0 · 25 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 5 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Soul House

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.0 mi

5.0 · 18 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 5 PM

Clothing StoresFurniture StoresGift Shops+5

Online Now

ZEN by Karen Moore Gemstone & Ocean Element Jewelry

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

5.0 · 11 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 6 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Kids outlet,key west fl 33040

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

5.0 · 10 ReviewsOpen now

Gift ShopsOptometristsEyewear Opticians+5

Online Now

Salty Rooster

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

5.0 · 4 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Jewelry StoreClothing StoreStore+1

Online Now

Frangipani Island Boutique

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

5.0 · 3 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 5 PM

Gift ShopJewelry StoreClothing Store+1

Online Now

Ocean Jewelers

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.7 mi

5.0 · 1 ReviewOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Jewelry StoreWholesalerManufacturer+1

Online Now

Shaddow and Fish

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

4.9 · 382 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 11 PM

Shoe StoresGift ShopsThrift Stores+2

Online Now

Blue Marlin Jewelry Key West

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

76 mi

4.9 · 329 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 5:30 PM

Jewelry StoreFinanceStore

Online Now

Pacific Jewelry

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.9 · 136 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Key West Treasure Chest

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.9 · 60 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 8 PM

Gift ShopsStore

Online Now

Good Day on a Happy Planet

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.9 · 36 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 8 PM

Gift ShopsGift ShopClothing Store+1

Online Now

Key West Local Luxe Jewelry

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.8 · 179 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Web DesignJewelry StoreStore

Earthbound Trading Co

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.8 · 146 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 9 PM

Gift ShopsThrift StoresMarketing Agencies+4

Online Now

Besame Mucho

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.8 · 103 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 6 PM

Gift ShopsThrift StoresGift Shop+1

Online Now

Silver & Gold

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.7 mi

4.8 · 56 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 8 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Blue Sophia Jewelry

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.8 · 48 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 6 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

IN TOUCH WITH YOU, LLC

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.8 · 21 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 6 PM

Gift ShopsGift ShopStore

Online Now

KEY WEST FINEST GOLD DAIMOND & TREASURE COINS BY RIHANNA JEWELS

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.7 mi

4.8 · 4 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 6:30 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

90 Miles To Cuba

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.7 · 379 ReviewsClosed · Opens Thu 12 PM

Furniture StoresGift ShopsArt Gallery+2

Neptune Designs

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.7 · 72 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 9 PM

Web DesignJewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Mine Shaft Jewelry Designs

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.7 · 38 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Jewelry StoreFinanceStore

Online Now

PHILIPPE SPENCER Goldsmiths of Fine Jewelry

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

4.7 · 3 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 5 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Mel Fisher's Treasures

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.6 · 115 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 7 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Jeff's Gems and Nautical Designs

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

4.6 · 103 ReviewsClosed · Opens 10 AM

Jewelry StoreStore

In One Era

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.7 mi

4.6 · 12 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11:30 AM

Furniture StoresGift ShopsThrift Stores+2

Graffitti Key West

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.5 · 74 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 6 PM

Shoe StoresShoe StoreClothing Store+2

Online Now

Forever Unique Permanent Jewelry

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.5 · 18 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 5 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

COACH Outlet

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.4 · 320 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 7 PM

Shoe StoresWomens Clothing StoreClothing Store+2

Online Now

Local Color

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.4 · 57 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 7:30 PM

Gift ShopsClothing StoreJewelry Store+2

Online Now

Touch of Gold

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.7 mi

4.4 · 14 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 6:30 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Clinton Square Market

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.7 mi

4.3 · 350 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 7 PM

Shopping MallTourist Attraction

Online Now

Nu Shuz

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.3 · 72 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Shoe StoresShoe StoreWomens Clothing Store+3

Online Now

Conch Jewelers

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.3 · 34 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

T.J. Maxx

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.2 · 912 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 9:30 PM

Shoe StoresDepartment StoreWomens Clothing Store+3

Online Now

Tucker's Provisions

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.2 · 47 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Shoe StoresGift ShopsStore

Online Now

Jean-Pierre Klifa Key West

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.1 · 38 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 7 PM

Clothing StoreStore

Online Now

Crystals and Coconuts

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.0 · 34 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 12 AM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Gold Creations

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.7 mi

4.0 · 23 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Capricorn Jewelry

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.0 · 8 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Dragonfly Imports

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.0 · 4 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 5 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Mac's Sea Garden

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

3.8 · 82 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 9 PM

Gift ShopsGift ShopStore

Online Now

Ocean Silver

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

3.8 · 5 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 9 PM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Made by Soto

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

2.6 mi

3.7 · 3 ReviewsClosed · Opens 10 AM

Jewelry StoreStore

Island Silver

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

3.3 · 13 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 12 AM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Liquid 8 Pawn LLC

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

0.4 mi

3.0 · 54 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 5:30 PM

FinanceStore

Online Now

Bronze Jewelers

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

2.6 mi

3.0 · 1 ReviewOpen now · Closes 4 AM

Jewelry StoreStore

Online Now

Indigo Boutique Key West

Jewelry Stores · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

2.7 · 65 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 5 PM

Shoe StoresWomens Clothing StoreClothing Store+1

Online Now

Need jewelry stores in Key West, FL?

Tell us what you need and get matched with top local options.

Methodology

Highest Rated starts with public rating values where available, with review count and name used as tie-breakers. External ratings are not RealReviews ratings.

External review ratings/counts are public-source context, not RealReviews ratings. Paid/sponsored/claimed status is not used as an organic ranking booster.

Read the ranking methodology

Quick compare in FL

Ballerina Jewelers396 public reviews

Shipwreck Treasures of the Keys358 public reviews

Emeralds International, LLC350 public reviews

Bliss Jewelers333 public reviews

Change the view

Highest ratedSort by rating signals

Most reviewedSort by public review counts

TopBalanced review-signal view