Most reviewed listings

Most reviewed Motels in Key West, FL

Compare Motels in Key West, FL. Use the sort controls to compare ratings, review counts, activity, and profile details.

Need motels in Key West, FL?

Tell us what you need and get matched with top local options.

Hilton Garden Inn Key West / The Keys Collection

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

0.8 mi

3.7 · 4,428 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Gift ShopsUtilitiesResort Hotel+5

Open now

Ibis Bay Beach Resort

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

4.0 · 4,324 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelResort HotelLodging

Beachside Resort & Residences

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

2.1 mi

4.3 · 3,530 ReviewsOpen now

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelWedding VenueResort Hotel+5

Open now

Havana Cabana

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.1 · 2,891 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelsHotelWedding Venue+3

Parrot Key Hotel & Villas

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

0.9 mi

4.3 · 2,388 ReviewsOpen now

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelResort HotelLodging

Open now

Courtyard by Marriott Key West Waterfront

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

2.0 mi

4.1 · 1,969 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelLodging

Best Western Hibiscus Motel

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.0 mi

4.5 · 1,604 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelLodging

NYAH Key West

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

3.9 · 1,486 ReviewsOpen now

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelLodging

Open now

Blue Marlin Motel

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

4.3 · 1,233 ReviewsOpen now

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

MotelLodging

Open now

Galleon Resort

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.6 · 1,147 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Resort HotelHotelLodging

Silver Palms Inn

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

0.9 mi

4.5 · 1,068 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelLodging

Southwinds Motel

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

4.2 · 1,066 ReviewsOpen now

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelMotelLodging

Open now

The Southernmost Inn

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

3.8 · 835 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelLodging

Open now

Seashell Motel

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

0.9 mi

3.7 · 809 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

MotelHostelLodging

The Palms Hotel

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

0.8 mi

4.1 · 709 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelInnGuest House+1

Open now

The Cabana Inn

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.1 · 578 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelLodging

Open now

Pegasus International Hotel

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

3.8 · 471 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelLodging

The Paradise Inn of Key West

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

4.2 · 452 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelLodging

Open now

Ella's Cottages - Key West Historic Inns

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

4.5 · 434 ReviewsOpen now

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

InnHotelGuest House+3

Open now

Almond Tree Inn

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

4.8 · 419 ReviewsOpen now

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelLodging

Open now

The Backyard Pool & Social Club

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.9 mi

4.1 · 415 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelsHotelLodging+1

Open now

Casablanca Hotel Key West

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.6 · 358 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelBed And BreakfastLodging

Harborside Motel & Marina

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

0.6 mi

4.4 · 303 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 8 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

MotelMarinaLodging

Open now

Coconut Beach Resort

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

0.9 mi

4.5 · 239 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 11 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelLodging

Open now

Suite Dreams Inn by the Beach

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

0.7 mi

4.3 · 118 ReviewsOpen now

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

InnGuest HouseLodging

Open now

Tranquility Guest House

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.7 · 95 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelGuest HouseLodging

Cayo Hueso Resorts

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

4.7 · 59 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Resort HotelHotelLodging

Key West Bahama House

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.3 · 53 ReviewsOpen now

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelLodging

Open now

Seaport Inn Key West

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.4 · 48 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Lodging

Hurricane Hole

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

2.4 mi

4.1 · 42 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsHotelsHotel+5

Sunset Pier

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.7 mi

4.5 · 39 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 5 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsBarsEvent Venues+5

Open now

Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.8 · 24 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 7 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Day SpasMedical SpasSkin Care+4

Open now

L-

Latitudes - Sunset Key Cottages

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.8 mi

4.3 · 12 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 4 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsBarsEvent Venues+5

Open now

Kay's Cottage

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

4.7 · 9 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 6 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Guest HouseLodging

Open now

Southernmost Beach Café

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

5.0 · 1 Review

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsEvent VenuesHotels+5

Open now

Blue Marlin Motel

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Days Inn

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

2.0 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

El Patio Motel

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

0.8 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

H2O Suites Hotel

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Jjjd

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

6.7 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Southwinds Motel

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.0 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

The Mustache Palace

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Truman Hotel

View profile

Motels · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Need motels in Key West, FL?

Tell us what you need and get matched with top local options.

Methodology

Most Reviewed starts with review counts where available, with rating and name used as tie-breakers.

Paid, sponsored, claimed, or verified status does not affect ranking order.

Read the ranking methodology

Quick compare in FL

Hilton Garden Inn Key West / The Keys Collection4,428 reviews

Ibis Bay Beach Resort4,324 reviews

Beachside Resort & Residences3,530 reviews

Havana Cabana2,891 reviews

Change the view

★

Highest ratedSort by rating strength

Most reviewedSort by review counts

TopBalanced review and activity view