Most reviewed listings

Most reviewed Seafood Restaurants in Key West, FL

Compare Seafood Restaurants in Key West, FL. Use the sort controls to compare ratings, review counts, activity, and profile details.

Need seafood restaurants in Key West, FL?

Tell us what you need and get matched with top local options.

Conch Republic Seafood Company

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.4 · 11,747 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 9:30 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantRestaurantFood

Open now

Blue Heaven

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.6 · 11,633 ReviewsClosed · Opens 5 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BarsAmerican RestaurantCaribbean Restaurant+4

El Meson De Pepe's Restaurant & Bar

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.7 mi

4.3 · 5,079 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BarsSeafood RestaurantCocktail Bar+5

Open now

Half Shell Raw Bar

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.4 · 4,762 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BarsSeafood RestaurantBar+2

Open now

DJ's Clam Shack

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.7 · 4,540 ReviewsClosed · Opens 5 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

DJsSeafood RestaurantRestaurant+1

Fogarty's

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.5 · 3,941 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 11 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BarsAmerican RestaurantBar And Grill+3

Open now

Harpoon Harry's

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.7 · 3,717 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 9 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

American RestaurantBreakfast RestaurantRestaurant+1

Open now

Alonzo's Oyster Bar

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.4 · 3,135 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantSports BarBar+2

Open now

Bagatelle

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.4 · 2,741 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantCaribbean RestaurantAmerican Restaurant+3

Open now

Dante's Key West Pool Bar & Restaurant

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.3 · 2,549 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BarsTest PrepRestaurant+5

Open now

Duffy's Steak & Lobster House

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

4.3 · 2,103 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Steak HouseAmerican RestaurantRestaurant+1

Open now

A&B Lobster House

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.4 · 2,101 ReviewsClosed · Opens 5:30 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantSteak HouseEvent Venue+3

Eaton Street Seafood Market

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.6 · 2,058 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 9 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantMarketRestaurant+1

Open now

First Flight Island Restaurant & Brewery

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.3 · 1,891 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BarsRestaurantBar+1

Open now

B.O.'s Fish Wagon

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.4 · 1,632 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 9 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Sandwich ShopFamily RestaurantFast Food Restaurant+4

Open now

Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

2.6 mi

4.5 · 1,621 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelsHotelResort Hotel+5

Open now

Martin's

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

4.4 · 1,118 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

European RestaurantRestaurantFood

Open now

7 Fish

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

0.9 mi

4.5 · 959 ReviewsClosed · Opens 6 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

RestaurantFood

Blackfin Bistro

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.6 · 830 ReviewsClosed · Opens 5 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BistroRestaurantFood

Little Pearl

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

4.6 · 812 ReviewsClosed · Opens 5 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

RestaurantFood

Lagerheads Beach Bar & Watersports

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.7 mi

4.5 · 713 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 7:30 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BarsBarAmerican Restaurant+2

Open now

Fisherman's Cafe

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.6 · 541 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 5 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

American RestaurantBreakfast RestaurantMeal Takeaway+4

Open now

Keys Fresh Seafood Market

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

3.0 mi

4.9 · 334 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 6 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

MarketFood

Open now

Dorada

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

0.8 mi

4.6 · 252 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 10 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

RestaurantFood

Open now

Bel Mare Restaurant

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.5 · 212 ReviewsClosed · Opens 5 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Fine Dining RestaurantRestaurantFood

Louie's Backyard

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.0 mi

4.7 · 78 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 11:30 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BarsBarRestaurant+1

Open now

Kaya Island Eats

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.7 · 65 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 1 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Event VenuesDJsEvent Venue+5

Open now

Hurricane Hole

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

2.4 mi

4.1 · 42 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelsMotelsHotel+5

Open now

Boat House Bar & Grill

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

4.9 · 33 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 6 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BarsEvent VenuesDJs+5

Four Marlins Oceanfront Dining

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.0 mi

3.4 · 18 ReviewsOpen now

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Event VenuesWedding VenueEvent Venue+4

Open now

L-

Latitudes - Sunset Key Cottages

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.8 mi

4.3 · 12 ReviewsClosed · Opens 9 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BarsEvent VenuesHotels+5

B.O.'s Fish Wagon

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Bahama Mama's Kitchen

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Carriage Trade Restaurant

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Conch Republic Seafood Company

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Conch Shack

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Courtyard Cafe

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Crabby Dick's

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

DJ's Clam Shack

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

American Restaurants

Doc's on Duval

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Duffy's Steak & Lobster House

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Fin

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Fisherman's Cafe

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Foxy's Bar & Grill

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

13 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Half Shell Raw Bar

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Hogfish Bar & Grill

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

3.0 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Hot Tin Roof Restaurant

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.8 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Keys Fisheries

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

0.8 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Little Pearl

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen

View profile

Seafood Restaurants · Key West, FL

2.7 mi

Profile details available

Quote request available · Claim available · Suggest a correction

Need seafood restaurants in Key West, FL?

Tell us what you need and get matched with top local options.

Methodology

Most Reviewed starts with review counts where available, with rating and name used as tie-breakers.

Paid, sponsored, claimed, or verified status does not affect ranking order.

Read the ranking methodology

Quick compare in FL

Conch Republic Seafood Company11,747 reviews

Blue Heaven11,633 reviews

El Meson De Pepe's Restaurant & Bar5,079 reviews

Half Shell Raw Bar4,762 reviews

Change the view

★

Highest ratedSort by rating strength

Most reviewedSort by review counts

TopBalanced review and activity view