Hotels in Key West, FL

H2O Suites is a small adults-only Old Town hotel near upper Duval Street, organized around 22 suites, a rooftop pool and bar, and select suites with private plunge pools. Its strongest fit is a quiet couples-oriented stay where privacy, suite space, and walkability matter more than a beach or full-resort scale.

24-hour concierge · Beach access · Concierge service · +3 more services

The Duval House is an adults-only historic hotel at 815 Duval Street, built from classic Conch-style structures surrounding a garden and pool. It offers a smaller guesthouse experience in the central Duval corridor rather than the facilities of a large waterfront resort. The strongest fit is an adult traveler who values walking access, garden character, and a central address. Historic room variation, stairs, street or courtyard orientation, parking, and nightlife noise should be checked for the exact category before booking.

Adults-only lodging · Breakfast service · Central Old Town location · +2 more services

Parrot Key Hotel & Villas is a tropical waterfront property on North Roosevelt Boulevard with rooms, suites, and multi-bedroom villas arranged around landscaped grounds. The official amenity list includes four pools, family lawn games, and scheduled transportation to Smathers Beach and downtown Key West. Its strongest use case is a family or group that values separated sleeping space and resort downtime more than immediate Duval Street walkability.

Family lawn activities · Four outdoor pools · Hotel rooms · +3 more services

Margaritaville Beach House Key West is a family-oriented hotel across South Roosevelt Boulevard from Smathers Beach, near Key West International Airport and several miles from central Old Town. It combines rooms and larger suites with a lagoon-style pool, on-site dining, parking, and scheduled transportation to the airport and Historic Seaport. Its value depends on using those amenities while accepting shuttle or ride planning for downtown.

Airport and downtown shuttle · Downtown and airport shuttle · Guest parking · +3 more services

Ibis Bay Beach Resort is a colorful retro-style waterfront property on North Roosevelt Boulevard with individually styled rooms, a pool, waterfront lounging, transportation into town, recreation rentals, and an on-site seafood restaurant. It is best understood as a casual 1950s motor-lodge-style resort rather than a polished luxury hotel.

Hotel rooms · On-site parking · On-site restaurant · +3 more services

Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton is a large historic Atlantic-side resort at 1500 Reynolds Street with renovated rooms and suites, a private beachfront, two pools, dining, spa and fitness services, watersports, and event space. It is strongest for travelers who will use a full resort rather than only sleep near Duval Street. Room category, building position, shoreline conditions, resort charges, parking, service expectations, and the complete cancellation terms should be checked for the actual dates.

Fitness center · Meeting and event space · On-site dining · +3 more services

Blue Flamingo Resort Key West is a North Roosevelt Boulevard resort with renovated rooms, multiple pools, on-site bars and food, games, pet options and a shuttle toward Old Town. Twelve dated Tripadvisor bodies, Booking verified-stay examples and fee/shuttle context from KAYAK and Expedia praise cleanliness, staff and amenities while flagging add-on costs, distance, shuttle limits and inherited maintenance or housekeeping variance. RealReviews finds High evidence, not a promise that every room or rate delivers the same stay.

Resort hotel

Casa Marina is a historic beachfront resort at 1500 Reynolds Street. Fourteen current verified bodies praise pools, cabanas, beach views, staff and food while documenting sargassum, room-size/age, noise, cleanliness, dining and fee/value tradeoffs. RealReviews reports High positive-skewed evidence and withholds a numeric score.

Beachfront historic resorts

Duval Gardens is not ready for a review profile because its public identity is inconsistent. Some surfaces use 1012 Duval Street, while Tripadvisor uses 1319 Duval Street and Hotels.com uses a Southernmost Beach Resort guesthouse label. KAYAK displays a 9.0 score from 1,296 ratings without visible bodies. Wanderlog exposes five Google-derived bodies mentioning both positive and negative stay details, but the address/operator relationship is unresolved. RealReviews marks the record Insufficient, quarantines the aggregates and publishes no score until the operator confirms the canonical property.

Adults-only guesthouse / bed and breakfast

Duval Inn is a small Old Town inn at 511 Angela Street, one block off Duval. Booking reports 7.9/10 from 581 verified stays and Tripadvisor 4.5/5 from 833 reviews. Twenty-six dated bodies were inspected: guests repeatedly praise walkability, friendly staff, clean grounds, the courtyard pool and adequate breakfast, while some report very small rooms or bathrooms, noise, AC or maintenance problems, uneven housekeeping response and value questions around parking or a resort fee. RealReviews assigns High evidence without publishing a proprietary score.

Hotels and inns

Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa is a 120-room waterfront hotel at 601 Front Street with a pool, spa, dining, marina and event facilities. Tripadvisor shows about 4,134 reviews at 4.3/5 and Booking.com 8.4/10 from 307 verified stays. Guests consistently value walkability, views, staff and cleanliness; the tradeoffs are premium pricing and fees, maintenance/noise variation and the need to distinguish waterfront access from a broad sandy beach.

Waterfront hotel and resort with spa, pool, dining and marina access

La Concha is a downtown Duval Street hotel at 430 Duval Street. Fourteen mixed bodies praise location, bars, concierge and updated rooms while documenting housekeeping, noise, maintenance and destination-fee tradeoffs. RealReviews labels the evidence High and scoreless.

Downtown hotels and historic Duval Street accommodations

Lighthouse Hotel is a historic inn at 902 Whitehead Street across from the Hemingway Home. Fourteen mixed bodies praise location, breakfast, pool, grounds and staff while documenting small rooms, access, housekeeping, parking and pool-scale tradeoffs. RealReviews labels the evidence High and scoreless.

Historic inns and boutique hotels