Top listings

Top Restaurants in Key West, FL

Compare Restaurants in Key West, FL. Use the sort controls to compare ratings, review counts, activity, and profile details.

Plan a meal

Request a table in Key West, FL

Share the date, preferred time, party size, and occasion with selected restaurants.

✓ Choose the restaurants✓ Add seating needs✓ Reservation requires confirmation

The restaurant must confirm the reservation.

Blue Heaven

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.6 · 11,633 ReviewsClosed · Opens 8 AM

Blue Heaven is a Bahama Village restaurant at 729 Thomas Street known for open-air courtyard dining, breakfast, dinner, live Key West character, and tall-meringue Key lime pie. Breakfast and lunch are currently first come, first served; dinner accepts limited reservations and walk-ins. The setting is a central part of the product, which makes heat, rain, waits, and outdoor seating relevant to the decision. It is best approached as a destination meal with schedule flexibility rather than a quick stop before a fixed departure.

Review data available · Services listed · Quote request available

BreakfastDinnerKey lime pie and bakery desserts+5

Sloppy Joe's Bar

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.5 · 15,149 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 4 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BarsDJsBar+5

Open now

Conch Republic Seafood Company

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.4 · 11,747 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11:30 AM

Conch Republic Seafood Company is a large waterfront restaurant in the Historic Seaport with a broad seafood menu, bar, and lively visitor-focused atmosphere. It works well for mixed groups that value location and menu range, while diners seeking a quiet or highly specialized meal may prefer a smaller room.

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsSeafood RestaurantRestaurant+1

El Siboney Restaurant (Downtown)

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

0.8 mi

4.6 · 6,692 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Cuban RestaurantRestaurantFood

Two Friends Patio Restaurant

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.4 · 6,979 ReviewsClosed · Opens 8 AM

Two Friends Patio Restaurant is a centrally located Old Town restaurant serving breakfast, seafood, drinks, and a broad visitor-friendly menu. Its patio and menu range suit mixed groups, while the busy entertainment-district setting can be louder and less intimate than a neighborhood restaurant.

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsBarsAmerican Restaurant+5

Better Than Sex - A Dessert Restaurant

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

4.8 · 4,953 ReviewsClosed · Opens 6 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Dessert RestaurantDessert ShopWine Bar+5

Margaritaville Restaurant - Key West

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.3 · 5,807 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BarsAmerican RestaurantSports Bar+3

DJ's Clam Shack

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.7 · 4,540 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsDJsSeafood Restaurant+2

Schooner Wharf Bar

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.5 · 4,847 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 2 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsBarsEvent Venues+5

Open now

Moondog Cafe Key West

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.7 · 4,357 ReviewsClosed · Opens 7:30 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsCoffee ShopsRestaurant+1

Caroline's Cafe

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.5 · 4,748 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

American RestaurantMeal DeliveryCaribbean Restaurant+4

El Meson De Pepe's Restaurant & Bar

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.7 mi

4.3 · 5,079 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsBarsSeafood Restaurant+5

Half Shell Raw Bar

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.4 · 4,762 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Half Shell Raw Bar is a casual open-air seafood restaurant at the Key West Historic Seaport, with raw-bar selections, oysters, peel-and-eat seafood, fish, drinks, and a working-harbor setting. Its strongest fit is an informal waterfront meal where atmosphere and seafood variety matter more than quiet, climate-controlled dining. Current menu prices, market-priced items, happy-hour details, waits, seating exposure, allergy handling, and large-party policies should be confirmed directly.

Review data available · Services listed · Quote request available

Bar serviceDinnerLunch+5

Harpoon Harry's

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.7 · 3,717 ReviewsClosed · Opens 6:30 AM

Harpoon Harry's is a classic diner near the Historic Seaport serving a broad, familiar breakfast and lunch menu. It is a practical choice for families and travelers who want an unfussy meal with better schedule control than a destination brunch, though the compact room can be busy.

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsAmerican RestaurantBreakfast Restaurant+2

Fogarty's

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.5 · 3,941 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsBarsAmerican Restaurant+4

Pepe's Cafe

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.5 · 3,764 ReviewsClosed · Opens 7:30 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsAmerican RestaurantRestaurant+1

Rams Head Southernmost

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.5 · 3,567 ReviewsClosed · Opens 8 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsBarsAmerican Restaurant+5

Garbo's Grill @ Hanks!

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.6 · 3,290 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

RestaurantHamburger RestaurantFast Food Restaurant+5

Alonzo's Oyster Bar

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.4 · 3,135 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsSeafood RestaurantSports Bar+3

Bagatelle

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.4 · 2,741 ReviewsClosed · Opens 9 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsSeafood RestaurantCaribbean Restaurant+4

Eaton Street Seafood Market

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.6 · 2,058 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Eaton Street Seafood Market combines a fish market with a casual counter-service lunch stop in Old Town. It is best approached for focused seafood, lobster rolls, sandwiches, and prepared catch rather than table-service ceremony; seating, specials, and supply can be limited.

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsSeafood RestaurantMarket+2

Dante's Key West Pool Bar & Restaurant

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.3 · 2,549 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BarsTest PrepRestaurant+5

Salute! On The Beach

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

0.7 mi

4.4 · 2,314 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsAmerican RestaurantWine Bar+4

The Stoned Crab

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

3.5 · 4,056 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantRestaurantFood

A&B Lobster House

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.4 · 2,101 ReviewsClosed · Opens 5:30 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantSteak HouseEvent Venue+3

Seaside Cafe at the Mansion

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

4.7 · 1,480 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11:30 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsBarsRestaurant+2

The Lobster Shack Key West

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

4.7 · 1,419 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsSeafood RestaurantRestaurant+1

Duffy's Steak & Lobster House

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

4.3 · 2,103 ReviewsClosed · Opens 12 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Steak HouseAmerican RestaurantRestaurant+1

Mary Ellen's Bar & Restaurant

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.7 · 1,281 ReviewsOpen now · Closes 2 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BarsAmerican RestaurantBar+2

Open now

Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

2.6 mi

4.5 · 1,621 Reviews

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

HotelsHotelResort Hotel+5

Thirsty Mermaid

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.5 · 1,562 ReviewsClosed · Opens 12 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsSeafood RestaurantRestaurant+1

Nine One Five

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

4.4 · 1,714 ReviewsClosed · Opens 5 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Tapas RestaurantBarRestaurant+1

First Flight Island Restaurant & Brewery

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.6 mi

4.3 · 1,891 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsBarsRestaurant+2

B.O.'s Fish Wagon

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.4 · 1,632 ReviewsClosed · Opens 7 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Sandwich ShopFamily RestaurantFast Food Restaurant+4

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.5 mi

4.7 · 969 ReviewsClosed · Opens 4 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantWine BarAmerican Restaurant+3

Mangoes Restaurant

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.1 · 2,152 ReviewsClosed · Opens 10 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Caribbean RestaurantBrunch RestaurantLounge Bar+5

Ocean Grill & Bar

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.2 mi

4.3 · 1,680 ReviewsClosed · Opens 10 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsSeafood RestaurantBar And Grill+4

The Docks Restaurant + Raw Bar

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

3.0 mi

4.7 · 869 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11:30 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsRestaurantSeafood Restaurant+1

The Waterfront Brewery

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.4 mi

4.3 · 1,612 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

BarsRestaurantBrewery+3

Mo's Restaurant

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

0.6 mi

4.7 · 748 ReviewsClosed · Opens 12 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Caribbean RestaurantRestaurantFood

Keys Fresh Seafood Market

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

3.0 mi

4.9 · 334 ReviewsClosed · Opens 9 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

MarketFood

Blackfin Bistro

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.6 · 830 ReviewsClosed · Opens 5 PM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

Seafood RestaurantsBistroRestaurant+1

Square Grouper Key West

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.3 mi

4.8 · 415 ReviewsClosed · Opens 11 AM

Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available

American RestaurantRestaurantFood

Little Pearl

View profile

Restaurants · Key West, FL

1.1 mi

4.6 · 812 ReviewsClosed · Opens 5 PM

Little Pearl is a small Old Town fish house and wine bar at the corner of Olivia and Elizabeth Streets. Its current format centers on a custom four-course dinner with scheduled seatings, making it better suited to a planned date night or food-focused evening than a flexible family meal. The residential setting, limited dining room, seafood emphasis, and structured pacing are the main reasons to choose it. Confirm the current menu, price, seating time, cancellation rule, and dietary accommodations directly before reserving.

Review data available · Services listed · Quote request available

Dinner reservationsFour-course dinnerSeafood-focused dining+4